Monday, 24 September 2012

Brochas: Daf Nun Beis amud beis



We do not recite blessing (for Havdalah) over the flame of gentiles...
It is understandable in respect of a flame, for it did not rest (on the Sabbath)

Rashi seems to suggest that there is a transgression ("aveira"). Despite the fact that one would expect this to be acceptable given that a gentile is permitted to light the lamp on Shabbos (since he has no mitzva to keep Shabbos), there is still apparently a hint of an aveira, given that it would have been forbidden for a Jew to complete the same action. The Taz (Orach Chaim 298:5) comments that this Gezeira is implemented despite the fact that a Jew is permitted to make use of a lamp lit by a gentile for his own use, since the blessing (as opposed to the use) requires there should be no hint of "aveira."

This prohibition is not extended writes the B'eer Haitiv to a lamp lit by a Jew from a lamp lit by a gentile.

No comments:

Post a Comment